Season Super Game Thread

[Maddawg]

So basically, the Marlins unarguably have a mediocre AAA team right now with no one on their 25 man roster included. Once a few veterans are traded, that means the mediocre AAA roster gets promoted and fills in the pieces around Anderson, Brinson, Rojas, Urena, Ca. Smith, Garcia, Steckenrider, Wittgren, Tayron, etc. PLUS the trade results. Realmuto/Bour/Straily/Castro/Barraclough/etc. is going to bring back A LOT, presumably multiple players MLB ready in AAA or higher.

Accordingly, your logic is dramatically flawed unless you think Anderson, Brinson, Rojas, Urena, Ca. Smith, Garcia, Steckenrider, Wittgren, Tayron, etc. are mediocre AAA players so the mean stays the same. I think that's a tough sell considering Anderson, Urena, Ca. Smith, and Rojas are on pace for 2.5 WAR seasons, the rest are clearly positive bullpen pieces, and who knows with Brinson but I bet he'd be one of the best players in AAA if he was demoted.

Basically, this hypothetical Marlins team would be the 1927 Yankees of AAA and the debate would be would they lose 35 games. If you're going to troll, be a better one.

lou I guess you have it all figuered out huh ? No the Marlins are barely a good AAA team right now and presumably the guys are traded for prospects and not MLB ready players. The trades they make will not make the team better this year and quite possibly next either. That is Jeters plan....just as the Astros and Cubs have done, and as the Phillies and Braves seemingly have done. I just won't believe the Marlins can do it. They have a history of NOT doing it. They have history of Brinson's throughout their history. (Allison, Hermida, Skipworth, Volstad, Booty, Jaime Jones, the whole 2005 1st round with 4 complete flops and Volstad, etc....) It's waaaaaaay more miss than hit. Whether trades or draft picks the Marlins have had HORRIBLE talent evaluation over all.

[fish16]

Lmao

- - - - - - - - - -

Classic Lou and his facts and data. Ever just predicted shit based off irrational emotion Lou??? Try it sometime!!

[lou]

lou I guess you have it all figuered out huh ? No the Marlins are barely a good AAA team right now and presumably the guys are traded for prospects and not MLB ready players. The trades they make will not make the team better this year and quite possibly next either. That is Jeters plan....just as the Astros and Cubs have done, and as the Phillies and Braves seemingly have done. I just won't believe the Marlins can do it. They have a history of NOT doing it. They have history of Brinson's throughout their history. (Allison, Hermida, Skipworth, Volstad, Booty, Jaime Jones, the whole 2005 1st round with 4 complete flops and Volstad, etc....) It's waaaaaaay more miss than hit. Whether trades or draft picks the Marlins have had HORRIBLE talent evaluation over all.

I forgot Denbo drafted Skipwoth and Sean West, and traded Cabrera for Maybin and a shitty Andrew Miller. My bad.

[fish16]

I forgot Denbo drafted Skipwoth and Sean West, and traded Cabrera for Maybin and a shitty Andrew Miller. My bad.

Don’t forget Allison and booty

[Maddawg]

I forgot Denbo drafted Skipwoth and Sean West, and traded Cabrera for Maybin and a shitty Andrew Miller. My bad.

The franchise is just cursed lou....Beinfest was horrendous here but came here with a good reputation. Denbo will turn into Dumbo on draft day....watch it happen.

[fish16]

The franchise is just cursed lou....Beinfest was horrendous here but came here with a good reputation. Denbo will turn into Dumbo on draft day....watch it happen.

The cynicism is unbelievably strong in you. Why watch and actively comment on something that is so clearly cursed and something that is so clearly doomed to fail then?

[gustavopim]

Juan Soto first pitch is a opposite field bomb.

I bet some dudes here were born in 2 months since they're so fast to discredit some players. If you took 9 months to be born ugly and dumb give a few months to players trying to adjust to the hardest league on the world.

[fish16]

Man there is no shot we can get soto anymore. Its absurd how fast they have moved him through the system this year and its not at all unreasonable given how good he is. I wonder if we have a shot at Robles instead of him now or if they just try to add elsewhere to their pitching considering they are also getting Murphy back from injury eventually as well as Robles coming back soon enough. They will probably settle for a lesser catching addition instead of JT.

[fish16]

Gonna have to start looking at other teams for JT. Minnesota is intriguing but id really want a power bat back for JT. Nick Gordon wouldnt be the end of the world though id prefer a much higher ceiling guy even tho he's got a pretty damn high floor. I want no part of the Mets system. Maybe the braves would be willing to deal from their pitching surplus and a guy like Riley and Pache or something?

- - - - - - - - - -

Ive yet to see him pitch live as i hadnt watched any of his previous games and just tuned in now to tonights game, but statistically Hernandez has looked like he has more than held his own thus far.

[Maddawg]

The cynicism is unbelievably strong in you. Why watch and actively comment on something that is so clearly cursed and something that is so clearly doomed to fail then?

Because of loyalty.....I am not going to be accused of running from the team, and being a bandwagon fan.

And NO OTHER fanbase can now be considered the most abused than the Marlins fans. My moaning, groaning, and trolling is a direct result of the teams colossal failures in the ownership, front office and on the field performance. 6 winning seasons in 25 years, soon to be 26 and in all likelyhood 27 years of team play. Not even the Cubs fans endured that kind of frustration. Only the Mariners fans have had to endure a longer post-season drought than Fish Fans, and Pirates fans more losing seasons than the Fish Fans have.

[geemoney]

My moaning, groaning, and trolling is a direct result of the teams colossal failures in the ownership, front office and on the field performance.

That's no reason to take it out on us.

[Maddawg]

That's no reason to take it out on us.

No place else to do it. This is the only forum I know of for the Marlins.

[Nick]

Because of loyalty.....I am not going to be accused of running from the team, and being a bandwagon fan.

I'd take any bandwagon fan over you.

[fish16]

I think Conley has a chance to be much more effective out of the bullpen. Lets see if he can do it. Would be nice if he can become a hard throwing lefty out of the pen who can go multiple innings.

- - - - - - - - - -

its been 2 ab's, im gonna say its the same old conley.

[fish16]

theyve just got to send brinson down already. pointless to continue to have him up here at all let alone batting him 8th every night.