Season Super Game Thread

[Maddawg]

Brinson looks lost up there. Send him down already.

Shhhhhh Fish16 will call you out for being negative about his baby. It's too early to be criticizing him. It might hurt the feelings of someone in the Marlins front office.




He's a bust, and Fish knows it....he just can't stand it that I'm (possibly) right.

- - - - - - - - - -

LOLOLOL well there ya go,.....he's sort of a bust LOL.

[Namaste]

He’s not a bust. He should not be in the majors.

The Marlins current plan has many flaws.

Brinson playing up here is one of them.

[Maddawg]

He’s not a bust. He should not be in the majors.

The Marlins current plan has many flaws.

Brinson playing up here is one of them.

Well Jeter has commanded that Brinson be up - because he's gonna like fill the stadium cuz, you know, he's a local kid....

- - - - - - - - - -

I guess if you guys keep telling yourself Brinson's not a bust, you'll really believe it one day.

But the numbers don't lie......we are 6 weeks into the season. This year to date + last year in Milwaukee, he has an MLB BA of .152. Sorry but that's not just "he needs to go down". He would be overmatched in AAA too. Just admit it we got fleeced in the Yelich trade (same old Marlins).

[gustavopim]

Starlin Castro is having some kind of night at the plate

- - - - - - - - - -

I can’t believe Steck walked Tucker on 4 pitches with Albies on deck

- - - - - - - - - -

Holy fuck, man.

Yeah. Walking Camargo with 2 outs ruined everything. I'm not even that mad. Like, I felt that we had some hard hit balls, bad luck and it was going to happen sometime with Steck. Hope he learns. It's his first (two) homers to LHH. Crazy

[fish16]

It’s crazy how maddawgs downtime interacts always with the marlins losing

[Lee Stone]

Weiters injured for Nationals. Time for Realmuto trade? Watching Acuna play, I'd like to have a player like that ... Robles. Maybe his being out with an injury and the Nats slow start make him available now. If not, a package of Kieboom, Raudy Read, and a pitching prospect might work.

[Nick]

I guess if you guys keep telling yourself Brinson's not a bust, you'll really believe it one day.

If I keep telling myself this makes sense, I'll really believe it one day.

[gustavopim]

Weiters injured for Nationals. Time for Realmuto trade? Watching Acuna play, I'd like to have a player like that ... Robles. Maybe his being out with an injury and the Nats slow start make him available now. If not, a package of Kieboom, Raudy Read, and a pitching prospect might work.

soto or bust

[Lee Stone]

soto or bust

Unfortunately, along with Guerrero Jr, Soto is about the only untouchable prospect.

[Namaste]

But the numbers don't lie......we are 6 weeks into the season. This year to date + last year in Milwaukee, he has an MLB BA of .152. Sorry but that's not just "he needs to go down". He would be overmatched in AAA too. Just admit it we got fleeced in the Yelich trade (same old Marlins).

Batting Average is the PERFECT statistic to cite for a debate like this.


I’m just kidding. It’s not.


Brinson has a 3.3 Defensive WAR and it’s only the 2nd week of May. His plate discipline is clearly not MLB ready but he’s not remotely a bust so get out of here with that Batting Average shit.

[fish16]

Also for the guy saying that I’m a Brinson lover, there is literally easily documented proof that I’ve been saying since spring training that his spring training counting stats aside, his k/B.B. ratio was horrific and I made it known for weeks before opening day that he should be sent down for a month and a half. Luckily we’ll get lucky eventually because he will go down for a month and we’ll get the extra year

- - - - - - - - - -

Maddawgs a troll anyways. The guy from the other site already confirmed

[Maddawg]

Maddawgs a troll anyways. The guy from the other site already confirmed

You can believe whatever you wish. It doesn't make it true. I had never heard of that site, and have never posted there. Is your proof that someone thinks it was me ? That sir is not proof, and if you live your life publishing things like this, and making false accusations against people you could eventually find yourself in a heap of legal trouble.

[Maddawg]

Batting Average is the PERFECT statistic to cite for a debate like this

Real numbers don't lie. Projections are just that, projecting the future, which is a risky business - because they can easily be wrong.

Brinson's performance on the field is evident. He is not an MLB caliber player. You have to be able to be an offensive player that can at least hit your own weight....he can't seemingly do that, let alone even hit the Mendosa Line.

It looks like they probably screwed up on the Yelich trade and if they did their rebuild is in extreme jeopardy right now. Satanton we all understand was a money dump, we get that.....the return wasn't going to be great. And Ozuna he's still a wild card because of Boras & signability. But in Yelich they HAD to be spectacular because he was controlable and the safest bet for any team trading for him.

They have to NAIL at least 1 starter in the drafts in 2018 and 2019, and trade Realmuto for at least 1 MLB starter or it's a failed rebuild and you are forced to spend more money than you want on Free Agency or it's at lesast another losing season at the MLB level. Can the fan base endure that ?

And of course the fans will be blamed for not coming out, even though MLB has not produced an organization that can even put a winning team for one season on the field. Around the country it's always the fans in Miami don't show up.....they had the MVP and didn't show up, ect.....it doesn't matter you need to win and there has been 2 winning seasons since 2003.....that's not 2 playoff teams, that's 2 winning seasons. That is a lot to ask of ANY fanbase much less one that has as many economic problems as there are in Miami.

[fish16]

and again, they STILL got a great deal for yelich, despite your unrelenting negativity.

[Nick]

I'll admit, I laughed at Satanton.