Florida Marlins All-Time Shortstop

[Ramp]

I didn't even have to think about it. Was Hanley all the way

[Swifty]

Swift if we're voting on who has the most highlights this is definitely the most merited for debate.

But if we're talking about who the best player is it's Hanley. Easily.

I would argue moments make the player. Reggie Jackson turned 'Reg-gie Reg-gie Reg-gie' into a number in monument park and a cap logo in Cooperstown. The body of work is incredibly important, but those 'moments' also count, I think a lot more than you're giving credit for.

[Bobbob1313]

Yeah, but a 200 point OPS advantage more than washes out those moments.

[dim]

Voted Gonzo not because he's a better Marlins SS than Hanley, but because Gonzo brings me back to a time when it was cool to have a Marlins team that actually appreciated good defense.

[Chewford]

Oh, Ice.

[HUGG]

Bass is my all-time favorite Marlin and I still didn't vote for him.