Florida Marlins All-Time Shortstop

[Party]

Walt Weiss






Kurt Abbott






Edgar "El Nino" Renteria

1997 World Champion
1998 All-Star






Alex Gonzalez

2003 World Champion
1999 All-Star






Hanley Ramirez



2006 Rookie of the Year
2008, 2009 & 2010 All-Star
2008 & 2009 Silver Slugger

[AdamRavs]

Walt Weiss is Hanley?? thats amazing
--------------------
I'm taking Gonzalez. The clutch HR he it. The awesome double play combo of him and Luis. Hanley is better offensively but overall I would rather have Gonzalez

[Metes]

Sorry Hanrey

Gonzo

[Bobbob1313]

Lol, on my phone, accidentally voted for Renteria. Please change to Hanley.

[Erick]

It's Hanley Ramirez.

[Omar]

I'm still amazed Sea Bass never won a GG with us

But yeah, it's gotta be Hanley

[Fritz]

Hanley

[Mainge]

Hanley.

[Metes]

I certainly hope we will have a chance to put Gonzo on the bench

[Swifty]

This is a tough position. Based on the reasoning I used to vote for Pudge, I should vote for Edgar (he beat the Giants in the DS and of course he has Game 7). Gonzo "feels" like he should be the guy; I know this sounds odd, but I look at his 8 seasons and really thought "that's it? it feels like he was here longer" but Hanley has a very good chance to be one of the two or three most talented players to ever wear a Marlins uniform. The fact that he's the only Marlin to win a batting title tipped it for me in his favor.

[Namaste]

Easily Hanley even though he was the worst last year.

[Swifty]

Why do you say 'easily'? I think of all the positions, this is the most merited for debate. 2 separate players who are very good in their own right with titles, being, more or less, instrumental parts in winning said titles, Edgar should have been ROY in '96, Gonzo should have at least one Gold-Glove. Hanley has a ROY, MVP runner up and batting title.

I repeat, this is almost certainly the toughest positional battle.
--------------------
Plus, if you were to list the greatest Marlins moments, Edgar and Gonzalez authored 2 of the top 3.

[HUGG]

Hanley

Edgar and Bass had moments, but both were incredibly mediocre overall (sub .700 ops).

[Namaste]

Swift if we're voting on who has the most highlights this is definitely the most merited for debate.

But if we're talking about who the best player is it's Hanley. Easily.

[Chewford]

I voted for the guy whose going to retire as a Marlin and have his number retired by the team.