If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
You don't strive to be league average. The other things are legit which is why I didn't reply specifically to them and admitted he is a better player than last year.
Are you seriously hating on Dee Gordon? He's been nothing but near perfect for over a month now. Saying "he can't sustain this, he's going to regress" is the most obvious and easy position I've ever seen anyone take on this board in 8 years. C'mon man! Everyone knows that. And clearly all his peripheral stats are up, so if you think you somehow know better than anyone here how he will look in 3 months, you need a dose of humility serum.
If the guy can hit .290/.330/.370+, with above average defense and the base running, he's going to be a 3.5+ WAR player and they have him for 3 more years. That seems kind of reasonable. The only thing I would be worried about is if they get stupid and give him an Elvis Andrus contract (8/$120... not a typo).
This is super fun, relatively unexpected, and a fantastic development if he is going to be a 4th really positive offensive player to add to the outfielders. We'll see how the season goes. He tailed off dramatically last year as someone already stated.
You don't strive to be league average. The other things are legit which is why I didn't reply specifically to them and admitted he is a better player than last year.
What's the saying?
"Don't let 'perfect' be the enemy of 'good.'"
With his baserunning abilities, a .340 OBP would be plenty fine for the leadoff spot in this era of diminished offense.
This "He's gonna hit .270" tip you're on is silly, I think.
It's a lot of a personal bias against his type of player. If he hits .300 the rest of the way great but if he finishes with a .300 ba that means he hit .270 from here on out and basically all of his value came from april which isn't good when we need the same if not more production in September
- - - - - - - - - -
also will he be affordable for the next 3 years while maintaining the ability to add a significant piece. currently the team looks pretty set for next year but the Braves and Mets will likely continue to improve and are playing better than expected thus far. I don't think you have the same expectations as coming into this season where you think picking up 45+ wins comes off of beating up the Braves Phil and mets.
- - - - - - - - - -
And can a mod or administrative please change my account name to simply to jay
IF Dee continues to hit well enough (ops+ over 100 is all you gotta ask for with everything else) and defend like this, his base running will very likely get better based off history, and you're looking at a ~4 WAR player.
If Heaney is a around league average era guy (he is considered a three, yah?), you're looking at 2.5 WAR. To be a 4 WAR SP, you're looking at needing an era of around 3/era plus of 115.
Pretty good trade atm. I'm willing to eat crow if Dee continues (assuming strait Dee for Heaney), but I do still hate the depth we gave up to get Haren. Those guys are probably nothing but bench/back up players but that's still an important role in a long season.
I really expected Bonifacio 2.0 (who tailed off hard after his one good season). Very happy that's not the case
Comment