Marlins 7 Game Win Streak Comes to an End As Houston Beats Fish 3-2

[Swifty]

I disagree with the notion that Gaby's good defensively. He makes most of the plays a 1B should make, but not all of them.

Defense would definitely improve with a Logan to first move.

[AdamRavs]

The problem is outside of 3 guys in the lineup the whole team is hitting for shit.. Buck, Reyes, Boner, Hanley.. Hanley has shown he can hit again but then next AB he is flailing around. It's a team issue. Not just Gaby.
--------------------
Lemme say this I don't love Gaby but who you gonna put in? Dobbs is not an everyday player. Petey play D well can't hit.

[MiamiHomer]

That's not a good excuse as to why Gaby should stay in the line up though.

[Mainge]

I disagree with the notion that Gaby's good defensively. He makes most of the plays a 1B should make, but not all of them.

Defense would definitely improve with a Logan to first move.

Nah he's been pretty damn good. Cmon.

[HUGG]

No one is saying Gaby is the only problem.

[Mainge]

The problem is outside of 3 guys in the lineup the whole team is hitting for shit.. Buck, Reyes, Boner, Hanley.. Hanley has shown he can hit again but then next AB he is flailing around. It's a team issue. Not just Gaby.
--------------------
Lemme say this I don't love Gaby but who you gonna put in? Dobbs is not an everyday player. Petey play D well can't hit.

Gaby has been by far the worst.

[Swifty]

The problem is outside of 3 guys in the lineup the whole team is hitting for shit.. Buck, Reyes, Boner, Hanley.. Hanley has shown he can hit again but then next AB he is flailing around. It's a team issue. Not just Gaby.
--------------------
Lemme say this I don't love Gaby but who you gonna put in? Dobbs is not an everyday player. Petey play D well can't hit.

Gaby's a lot worse than any of those other players right now. He's not walking and he's K'ing a lot.

[AdamRavs]

Before these last two games it was Buck. I mean bench him move LoMo your just shifting a problem then to left field.

[Swifty]

Nah he's been pretty damn good. Cmon.

Disagree.

[Mainge]

Gaby's a lot worse than any of those other players right now. He's not walking and he's K'ing a lot.

Yeah. I was against replacing him earlier because it was too soon, but we're past that.

[Swifty]

Before these last two games it was Buck. I mean bench him move LoMo your just shifting a problem then to left field.

Buck's terrible. I don't like any aspect of his game at all and he's considerably outperforming Gaby.

[MiamiHomer]

Before these last two games it was Buck. I mean bench him move LoMo your just shifting a problem then to left field.

I'd rather have a good defensive LFer out there with limited offense than the current situation.

[AdamRavs]

Its not gonna solve our offensive problem which is the root cause of this discussion

[Mainge]

Disagree.

Find but you're wrong.

[Mainge]

Its not gonna solve our offensive problem which is the root cause of this discussion

It will help it.