Florida Marlins All-Time Second Baseman

[Party]

Bret Barberie

Original Marlin





Quilvio Veras





Craig "Llovisnitas" Counsell



1997 World Champion



Luis Castillo



2003 World Champion
2002, 2003 & 2005 All-Star
2003, 2004 & 2005 Gold Glove Award Winner

Franchise leader in:
At-bats (4,347)
Bases on Balls (533)
Games (1,128)
Hits (1,273)
Runs (675)
Stolen Bases (281)
Triples (42)



Dan "His Name is Dan Uggla" Uggla



2006 & 2008 All-Star
2010 Silver Slugger

Franchise leader in:
Home Runs (154)



Other players can be nominated, and posts 'nominating' them will be counted as votes if they receive at least two votes.

Voting lasts seven days.

[Miamarlin21]

I can't decide between Louis or Uggla.

[Party]

I think this is a slam dunk.

Luis had above average defense. Dan Uggla had three errors in the All-Star Game.

[Bobbob1313]

I think this is a slam dunk.

Luis had above average defense. Dan Uggla had three errors in the All-Star Game.

I get what you're saying, but this is a dreadful way to say it.
--------------------
I realize I picked Pudge for his one season, ignoring CJ's longevity, but I give Luis the nod here for his longevity and defense + major contribution to a WS team.

[Metes]

Shameful if Louie isn't unanimous

[Chewford]

It's Luis. That is a statement of both opinion and absolute, undeniable fact.

[Mainge]

Louie.

[lou]

Shameful if Louie isn't unanimous

Agree completely

[HUGG]

Luis.

He can't hear any argument for Uggla because he has his 2 championship rings in his ears.

[Bobbob1313]

Uggla is the franchise leader in HRs, right?

[HUGG]

Yes
--------------------
1. Dan Uggla 154
2. Mike Lowell 143
3. Miguel Cabrera 138
4. Hanley Ramirez 134
5. Derrek Lee 129
6. Gary Sheffield 122
7. Jeff Conine 120
8. Cliff Floyd 110
9. Preston Wilson 104
10. Alex Gonzalez 81

[Bobbob1313]

In the interest of fairness, since we're including that Luis is the franchise leader in Triples, shouldn't that be under his bio?

[Metes]

Luis.

He can't hear any argument for Uggla because he has his 2 championship rings in his ears.

He was actually in AAA in 97, so just 1 ring

[Party]

It was overlooked.

[Fritz]

Luis.