Florida Marlins All-Time Catcher

[Omar]

Benito Santiago



Original Marlin



Charles Johnson



1997 World Champion
1997 & 2001 All-Star
1995, 1996, 1997 & 1998 Gold Glove Winner



Mike Redmond



2003 World Champion



Ivan "Pudge" Rodriguez



2003 World Champion
2003 NLCS MVP



Miguel Olivo







Other players can be nominated, and posts 'nominating' them will be counted as votes if they receive at least two votes.

Voting lasts seven days.

[Metes]

Loved Pudge the most but have to go CJ for body of work

[emkayseven]

wut Meats sed

[dim]

I would've said CJ, but I think Pudge's one season here played a bigger role in our team history than all our other catcher's seasons combined.

[Ramp]

I'm with MK and Metes

[TealMonster08]

I think body of work gives it to CJ easily.

[Omar]

I'm with the crowd thus far. In a Marlin uniform, CJ was better

[Bobbob1313]

CJ never had as good a season as Pudge's season here, and Pudge was the catalyst for a championship. I'll take the brief lofty high over the decent tenure.

[emkayseven]

Mitch Lyden

[Metes]

CJ never had as good a season as Pudge's season here, and Pudge was the catalyst for a championship. I'll take the brief lofty high over the decent tenure.

I get that line of reasoning

For me, it's the fact that CJ was our organic guy, we drafted him, he was really the franchise player in the team's infancy, whereas Pudge was the hired gun

[Ramp]

CJ never had as good a season as Pudge's season here, and Pudge was the catalyst for a championship. I'll take the brief lofty high over the decent tenure.

not even CJ's 1997?

[Bobbob1313]

not even CJ's 1997?

Played in more games, was a better hitter, and while BR has CJ as almost 2 wins better defensively, I think that's overstating it quite a bit.

[Omar]

How? CJ was a monster defensively. First GG winner for the Fish if I remember correctly

Mitch Lyden

No voting twice

[Bobbob1313]

How? CJ was a monster defensively. First GG winner for the Fish if I remember correctly


No voting twice

Pudge was pretty solid too, no?

[Fritz]

No love for Mike Piazza?